UTOPIA by Travis Scott album cover

Album review · 2023

Travis Scott - UTOPIA Album Review

Travis Scott
Released
2023
Genre
Hip-Hop
Label
Cactus Jack
Producers
WondaGurl, Kanye West, Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo
Features
Drake, Beyoncé, Playboi Carti
Read time
12 min
Published
Updated
All Travis Scott albums ranked →
6.3

The scorecard

6.3/10 · Mixed

How we score →
Writing25%
5.0

Lyrically minimal throughout, relying on ad-libs and atmosphere over substance, with even the attempted deeper cuts like fatherhood on "My Eyes" more competent than compelling.

Production25%
8.0

The psychedelic rock pivot works on "Modern Jam," the beat switches on "Meltdown" and "Telekinesis" are expertly timed, and the orchestration on "Til Further Notice" justifies the five-year wait, though not every track reaches that level.

Delivery15%
6.5

Flow is varied from the manic energy on "FE!N" to the melodic stretches on "My Eyes," and while he cedes ground to guests who often outshine him, his own performances are solid.

Cohesion15%
5.5

The middle sags under its own length—nineteen tracks is at least three too many, and the sequencing from "Topia Twins" to "Skitzo" feels arbitrary—but the front half flows well from "Hyaena" through "Sirens."

Originality10%
6.0

Kanye's shadow looms heavy on "Modern Jam" and "Thank God," blurring homage and recycling, even as the psychedelic rock experiments and orchestral flourishes push past the Astroworld formula.

Replay value10%
6.5

The production depth rewards repeat listens even when the writing doesn't, and the hits—"Meltdown," "FE!N," "Telekinesis"—should prove durable.

Travis Scott UTOPIA — When the Spectacle Finally Delivered the Goods

Five years is long enough to reinvent yourself or dig a deeper hole in the same dirt. Travis Scott spent the gap between Astroworld and UTOPIA threatening both: teasing psychedelic rock pivots, working with Rick Rubin, playing new material at the Pyramids before the Egyptian government shut it down. The rollout promised transformation. The album delivers something more modest and more valuable: proof that Scott's aesthetic—maximal production, minimal writing, guests doing the heavy lifting—can still justify its own excesses when the beats are this good.

UTOPIA is his best record because it is his most expensive-sounding, which in his case is not a shallow compliment. The production here, helmed by a small army including WondaGurl, Kanye West, Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo, James Blake, and the Alchemist, does not just serve the songs; it is the songs. Scott remains a better curator than rapper, and on UTOPIA he curates at a level Astroworld only hinted at.

The psychedelic rock he promised shows up in flashes—MODERN JAM samples an early Kanye demo and bends it into something stranger, PARASAIL floats on a Dave Bixby sample that sounds like it was recorded in a canyon. The orchestration on TIL FURTHER NOTICE and the beat switches on MELTDOWN and TELEKINESIS justify the five-year wait in a way that, say, another verse about Lamborghinis would not. But the album is too long, the middle sags, and Scott's writing remains his weakest tool.

When he hands the mic to Beyoncé, Drake, Playboi Carti, or Westside Gunn, the album comes alive. When he is alone, it coasts on vibes.

The question is whether vibes this expensive and this well-executed still count as substance, and for nineteen tracks the answer is mostly yes?

The Studio as Instrument, the Rapper as Conductor

Scott has always treated production as the lead and his rapping as texture, and UTOPIA pushes that dynamic further than any of his prior records. The credits read like a summit: WondaGurl and Jahaan Sweet on multiple tracks, Kanye West on THANK GOD and TELEKINESIS, Boi-1da and Vinylz on MELTDOWN, the Alchemist on LOST FOREVER, Metro Boomin on TIL FURTHER NOTICE. The result is an album that sounds like it cost a fortune and knows it.

MODERN JAM is the psychedelic rock experiment made real: Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo co-produces, and the track samples an early version of Kanye's "I Am a God" before warping it into something looser and weirder, with Teezo Touchdown's vocals adding a punk edge Scott has never approached on his own. MELTDOWN is a masterclass in structure—Boi-1da, Tay Keith, and Bnyx layer a beat that shifts twice, giving Drake room to slide and Scott space to bark. TELEKINESIS builds to a crescendo with live strings and a Kanye co-credit that is audible in the gospel undertones. TIL FURTHER NOTICE closes with James Blake on keys and Metro Boomin on drums, creating the most patient, least Travis-like moment in his catalog.

The writing, predictably, does not match the production. Scott's verses are still built on ad-libs, Auto-Tuned melodies, and broad gestures rather than specific images. When he tries for substance—MY EYES has him reflecting on fatherhood, GOD'S COUNTRY nods to his Houston roots—the lines are more competent than compelling. He is better at setting a mood than making a point, and UTOPIA leans into that, often to its benefit.

The guests do the real rapping.

Playboi Carti on FE!N brings manic energy that Scott matches but does not exceed. Beyoncé on DELRESTO (ECHOES) elevates the track into something grander than Scott could manage alone. Westside Gunn on LOST FOREVER delivers the sharpest bars on the album over an Alchemist beat that sounds like it wandered in from another project entirely. The Weeknd, Bad Bunny, SZA, Future, 21 Savage, and Kid Cudi all get real estate, and most of them use it better than the host.

Scott's delivery has improved—his flow on FE!N is genuinely unhinged, his melodic runs on MY EYES and LOOOVE show more range than the Astroworld cuts—but he is still more convincing as a vibe-setter than a technician.

The album's biggest weakness is its length. Nineteen tracks is a statement of ambition, but it also means filler. TOPIA TWINS with Rob49 and 21 Savage is fine but forgettable. SKITZO with Young Thug runs over six minutes and does not earn half of them.

PARASAIL is a two-and-a-half-minute interlude with Yung Lean and Dave Chappelle that feels like a sketch idea stretched too thin. The sequencing works in the first half—HYAENA to SIRENS is a strong opening run—but loses focus in the middle, where the album starts to feel like a playlist rather than a statement.

Nineteen Tracks, Twelve That Matter

UTOPIA is frontloaded by design. The opening stretch from the first track through the first six is the strongest sequence Scott has ever assembled, setting the tone and delivering on the psychedelic rock promise while maintaining momentum throughout. The commercial peak arrives early, with collaborations that work because both artists stay in their lanes.

The middle third sags. One highlight breaks through—a skeletal, hard-hitting collaboration—but the surrounding run feels like Scott clearing out the vault rather than building to anything. One track tries to recover with high-profile guests, and it succeeds on production alone, but by that point the album has already started to drag.

The back half tightens up. LOST FOREVER is a genuine detour, and it works precisely because of that contrast. The closing run reunites Scott with familiar collaborators, resulting in material that is warmer and more human than most of what precedes it.

The final stretch includes the album's most ambitious moment, building to an orchestral climax. The closer gives Scott space to sound vulnerable rather than just loud. The pacing is uneven, but the peaks are high enough to justify the length for anyone willing to skip past the valleys.

The Best Travis Scott Album Because It Sounds Like It Cost the Most

UTOPIA is Travis Scott's best album because it is the fullest expression of what he does well: expensive, meticulously constructed production that compensates for his limited writing. The psychedelic rock experiments are real, the orchestration is genuinely ambitious, and the guest list is stacked with artists who bring their A-material. It is also too long, lyrically thin, and heavily indebted to Kanye West in ways that blur homage and imitation. But the production is so strong—WondaGurl, the Alchemist, Metro Boomin, James Blake, and a dozen others all working at a high level—that the album justifies its excesses more often than not.

It is a curator's record, and Scott is a better curator than he has ever been. Where it ranks in the catalog is clear: ahead of Rodeo, Birds in the Trap, and even Astroworld, which had higher peaks but more filler. UTOPIA is more consistent in its ambition, even if it does not always deliver on it.

The production alone makes it essential for anyone interested in where rap can go when budget is no object. The writing makes it skippable for anyone who needs bars over vibes. Who should start here: fans of Astroworld looking for a more expensive version of the same thing, production nerds who want to hear what happens when you put the Alchemist and Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo on the same tracklist, and anyone who thinks Travis Scott's best skill is knowing who to put in the room. Who should skip it: anyone allergic to Auto-Tune, anyone looking for quotable verses, and anyone who thought Rodeo was more focused.

Start with MELTDOWN, FE!N, and TELEKINESIS—those three tracks capture the album's strengths and skip past most of its dead weight. If those work, try LOST FOREVER for the Alchemist beat and TIL FURTHER NOTICE for the James Blake closer. For the next listen, go back to Astroworld and hear how much further Scott pushed the sound here. For a different take on expensive maximalism, try Kanye West's My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, which looms over this album whether Scott admits it or not.

UTOPIA is not a landmark record, but it is the sound of an artist finally learning how to make his limitations work for him instead of against him.

Track by track

Track Listing

#Title
1

HYAENA

Standout

Opens with a Funkadelic sample and distorted bass that sets the album's tone: dense, expensive, and more interested in atmosphere than clarity. Scott's flow is aggressive but the lyrics are vague, relying on energy over substance. The Gentle Giant sample adds a proggy edge that hints at the psychedelic rock Scott promised. Strong opener that establishes the production standard for what follows.

2

THANK GOD

Solid

Kanye West co-produces and his influence is heavy—the beat sounds like a Donda offcut, gospel undertones and all. Scott raps about gratitude and survival, but the writing is more mood than message. KayCyy and Teezo Touchdown add uncredited vocals that give the track texture. Solid but derivative, and the Kanye shadow is impossible to ignore.

3

MODERN JAM

Standout

The psychedelic rock experiment made real. Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo co-produces, and the track samples an early version of Kanye's "I Am a God" before warping it into something looser and stranger. Teezo Touchdown's vocals add a punk edge Scott has never approached on his own. The guitars are fuzzed out, the drums are loose, and the whole thing sounds like Scott finally trying something new instead of refining the old formula. One of the album's best tracks.

4

MY EYES

Standout

Floats on a sample from the Japanese House that Wheezy and Buddy Ross turn into something spectral. Scott raps about fatherhood and responsibility, and the writing is more specific than usual—still not sharp, but competent. Sampha and Justin Vernon add uncredited vocals that give the track a sense of space. The production is patient and the mood is reflective, making it one of the album's more human moments.

5

GOD’S COUNTRY

Solid

Originally a Kanye West song intended for Donda, now repurposed for Scott. At just over two minutes, it is more sketch than song—Scott raps about Houston and his roots, but the track ends before it builds to anything. The production is stark and effective, but the brevity makes it feel like an interlude rather than a statement.

6

SIRENS

Standout

Slows the pace without losing momentum. The production, handled by multiple contributors including John Mayer, layers a sample from New England's "Explorer Suite" with Amanaz's "Nsunka Lwendo" to create something eerie and textured. Drake adds uncredited vocals that blend into the background rather than dominating. The track works as a mood piece, and Scott's delivery is more melodic than aggressive, giving the album a necessary breather before "Meltdown."

7

MELTDOWN

Standout

The album's commercial peak and one of its best tracks. Boi-1da, Vinylz, Tay Keith, and Bnyx layer a beat that shifts twice, giving Drake room to slide and Scott space to bark. Drake's verse is effortless, Scott's hook is catchy, and the production is sharp enough to justify the hype. The beat switches are expertly timed, and the whole thing feels like a hit without sounding calculated. Debuted at number three on the Hot 100 for a reason.

8

FE!N

Standout

Playboi Carti brings manic energy and Scott matches it, trading ad-libs and distorted vocals over a skeletal Jahaan Sweet beat. The production is hard and minimal, giving both rappers room to go unhinged. Carti's verse is the highlight—his flow is more unpredictable and his energy is higher. Scott holds his own, but this is Carti's track. Debuted at number five and became a fan favorite for good reason.

9

DELRESTO (ECHOES)

Standout

Beyoncé elevates this into something grander than Scott could manage alone. The production, co-helmed by Hit-Boy and Beyoncé herself, is lush and layered, with Justin Vernon adding uncredited vocals that give the track a sense of scale. Scott raps about legacy and ambition, but Beyoncé's presence is what makes the track memorable. She does not dominate—this is still Scott's song—but her verse and her vocal runs add a level of craft that highlights what Scott lacks. Strong single material.

10

I KNOW ?

Solid

Oz and Derek "206" Anderson produce a beat that is more restrained than most of the album, giving Scott room to rap without competing with the production. The writing is still vague—he raps about loyalty and success—but the flow is confident and the hook is sticky. The track debuted at number eleven and was released as the fourth single. Solid but not essential, and it works better in the context of the album than on its own.

11

TOPIA TWINS

Solid

Rob49 and 21 Savage get verses, and both are competent but forgettable. The production, handled by Wheezy and others, is fine but unremarkable. Scott's hook is serviceable, and the track functions as a breather between the album's peaks, but it does not add much. Filler.

12

CIRCUS MAXIMUS

Solid

The Weeknd and Swae Lee contribute, and the production is strong—WondaGurl and Jahaan Sweet build a beat that is expansive and layered. The Weeknd's verse is polished, Swae Lee's hook is melodic, and Scott holds the center without standing out. The track works on production alone, but by this point in the album the guest-heavy formula is starting to feel repetitive.

13

PARASAIL

Solid

A two-and-a-half-minute interlude with Yung Lean and Dave Chappelle. The production samples Dave Bixby's "Drug Song" and sounds like it was recorded in a canyon—spacious and strange. Yung Lean's verse is more interesting than Scott's, and Chappelle's spoken-word contribution feels like a sketch idea stretched too thin. The track works as a mood piece but not much else.

14

SKITZO

Weak

Over six minutes long and does not earn half of them. Young Thug gets a verse, and he is solid, but the track meanders. The production, handled by Boi-1da and a team of others, has moments—there are interesting switches in the back half—but the length kills the momentum. Scott's writing is at its weakest here, relying on ad-libs and Auto-Tune runs that do not go anywhere. Should have been cut or trimmed to three minutes.

15

LOST FOREVER

Standout

A genuine detour. Westside Gunn raps over an Alchemist beat that sounds like it wandered in from another project entirely—dusty loops, minimal drums, none of the maximalism that defines the rest of the album. Gunn's verse is sharp and specific, the best bars on the record. James Blake co-produces and adds subtle keys. The track works precisely because it has nothing to do with the rest of UTOPIA, and it is a welcome contrast. One of the album's highlights.

16

LOOOVE

Standout

Pharrell produces and Kid Cudi guests, reuniting the trio from earlier collaborations. The production is warmer and more human than most of what precedes it—Pharrell's drums are crisp, the melody is sun-soaked, and Cudi's verse is nostalgic without being sentimental. Scott raps about love and relationships, and the writing is more earnest than usual. The track feels like a callback to an earlier era of Scott's sound, and it works as a palate cleanser.

17

K‐POP

Solid

Bad Bunny and the Weeknd guest on the album's lead single. The production, handled by Illangelo and Boi-1da, is polished and commercial, built for playlists. Bad Bunny's verse is in Spanish and adds a global edge, the Weeknd's hook is melodic, and Scott does his job without standing out. The track is fine—catchy, expensive-sounding—but it is also the most obvious single on the album, and it feels a bit calculated compared to the weirder moments elsewhere.

18

TELEKINESIS

Standout

The album's most ambitious moment. SZA and Future trade verses over a beat that builds to an orchestral climax, with live strings performed by a quartet. Kanye West co-produces, and his influence is audible in the gospel undertones and the way the track swells. SZA's verse is polished, Future's is effortless, and Scott's hook ties it together. The production is dense and layered, rewarding repeat listens. The beat switches are expertly timed, and the orchestration in the back half justifies the five-year wait. One of the album's best tracks.

19

TIL FURTHER NOTICE

Standout

James Blake co-produces and guests, and Metro Boomin handles drums. The track is the most patient and least Travis-like moment in his catalog—Blake's keys are delicate, the tempo is slow, and Scott's vocals are more restrained than anywhere else on the album. 21 Savage gets a verse and he is solid, but this is Blake's track. The production is gorgeous, and the track works as a closer because it does not try to be a victory lap. It ends the album on a reflective note rather than a bombastic one, and that choice feels earned.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Travis Scott UTOPIA better than ASTROWORLD?
Yes, UTOPIA is Travis Scott's best album. While ASTROWORLD had higher individual peaks like "SICKO MODE," UTOPIA is more consistent in its ambition and features stronger production across the board. The psychedelic rock experiments on tracks like "Modern Jam" and the orchestration on "Telekinesis" push past the Astroworld formula. It suffers from excessive length—nineteen tracks is at least three too many—but the front half and closing stretch are the best work Scott has ever assembled.
What are the best songs on Travis Scott UTOPIA?
The essential tracks are "Meltdown" with Drake, "FE!N" with Playboi Carti, and "Telekinesis" with SZA and Future. "Modern Jam" delivers the psychedelic rock Scott promised, "Lost Forever" features Westside Gunn over an Alchemist beat, and "Til Further Notice" closes the album with James Blake's keys. "My Eyes" and "Delresto (Echoes)" with Beyoncé are also strong. Start with those seven and skip the middle sag from "Topia Twins" to "Skitzo."
Who produced Travis Scott UTOPIA?
UTOPIA features production from WondaGurl, Kanye West, Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo from Daft Punk, James Blake, the Alchemist, Metro Boomin, Boi-1da, Tay Keith, Hit-Boy, Pharrell, and Jahaan Sweet, among others. The stacked credits deliver: the psychedelic experiments on "Modern Jam," the beat switches on "Meltdown" and "Telekinesis," and the orchestration on "Til Further Notice" justify the five-year gap since ASTROWORLD. The production is the album's greatest strength.
How long is Travis Scott UTOPIA?
UTOPIA runs nineteen tracks and approximately seventy-three minutes, which is at least three tracks too long. The front half from "Hyaena" through "Meltdown" flows well, and the closing stretch from "Lost Forever" to "Til Further Notice" is strong, but the middle third sags. Tracks like "Topia Twins," "Skitzo," and "Parasail" feel like filler, and the sequencing in that section is arbitrary. A tighter fifteen-track version would rank even higher.

Featured in these lists