Milky Way by Bas album cover

Album review · 2018

Bas - Milky Way

Bas
Released
2018
Genre
Hip-Hop
Label
Dreamville
Producers
J. Cole, Ron Gilmore, Sango
Features
J. Cole, Ari Lennox, ASAP Ferg
Read time
9 min
Published
Updated
All Bas albums ranked →
6.7

The scorecard

6.7/10 · Good

How we score →
Writing25%
6.5

Bas finds specific imagery in pockets (the Miami heat on "Boca Raton," the self-examination on "Purge") but often settles for vague affirmations about growth and grounding that the verses don't make concrete.

Production25%
7.5

J. Cole, Sango and Childish Major build airy, sample-flipped soundscapes that split the difference between jazz-inflected boom bap and contemporary drift, though the consistency across fourteen tracks sometimes flattens where it could have pushed dynamics harder.

Delivery15%
6.0

Bas's unhurried, conversational flow sounds pleasant but rarely commands the track, and his hooks coast on melody rather than lyrical content while guest verses from Cole and Ferg expose the gap in presence.

Cohesion15%
7.0

The album sequences like a long evening that peaks early with "Tribe" and "Boca Raton," then coasts through the middle stretch without sagging but also without developing the mood into distinct chapters.

Originality10%
5.5

The jazz-rap production and introspective angle echo Cole's blueprint without adding much new, and while the Miami-inflected sequencing gives it a distinct mood, it never develops into a distinct vision.

Replay value10%
6.5

The production holds up better than the writing on repeat visits, with tracks like "PDA" and "Designer" rewarding attention to instrumental layers even as the verses rarely reveal more depth.

Bas Milky Way — Finding Ground on Someone Else's Map

Milky Way stakes its claim in the first lines of "Icarus": Bas wants to find ground, to escape the chase for external validation and tether himself to something real. The thesis runs through all fourteen tracks—love of self, love that fills the well instead of poisoning it—but the album never digs deep enough to earn it.

Bas moved from Queens to Miami between albums, and Milky Way sounds like someone who figured out the vibe of a new city without yet understanding what it means to live there. The production, handled largely by J. Cole, Ron Gilmore and a small crew including Sango and Childish Major, is the album's spine: jazz-flipped, sample-heavy, warm in the low end and spacious in the arrangement. The beats do more interpretive work than the rapping.

When Bas locks in—on "Tribe," on the second half of "Purge"—he demonstrates real technical control and a knack for conversational phrasing that never sounds forced. But across thirty-nine minutes he coasts more often than he digs, and the introspection he promised in his Instagram announcement stays surface-level. The result is an album built for enjoyment rather than examination: solid on first listen, pleasant on repeat, and not quite strong enough to justify the grand framing.

The Sound That Carries Him

The production is what holds this together. J. Cole appears on seven tracks as a producer and co-signs the entire sonic approach: sample-driven, jazz-inflected, warm but not dense, with enough negative space for Bas to breathe and enough low-end bounce to keep the tempo conversational. Sango's work on "Boca Raton" flips Gil Scott-Heron into a Miami heat shimmer; Childish Major builds "Tribe" around an Edu Lobo sample that swings without cluttering the pocket. Ron Gilmore co-produces ten of the fourteen tracks and anchors the album's consistency—everything sounds like it belongs on the same record without sounding repetitive. The sequencing uses two brief film-sample interludes ("Infiniti" from White Men Can't Jump, "Great Ones" from A Bronx Tale) to break the album into movements, and both land without disrupting the flow.

Bas writes in images when he focuses: the self-scrutiny on "Purge" about poisoning your own well, the Miami block party energy on "Boca Raton," the late-night clarity on "PDA." But the writing too often substitutes vibe for specificity. Verses about growth and grounding and learning to love yourself drift by without sharp details or surprising turns of phrase. His rhyme schemes stay functional—couplets and simple internal patterns that serve the flow but rarely call attention to themselves—and he leans on melody in the hooks rather than crafting lines that stick. The wordplay is competent but not inventive; the storytelling is more mood than narrative. He never embarrasses himself, but he rarely commands the track the way Cole does on "Tribe" or the way ASAP Ferg does on "Boca Raton."

Bas's delivery is his clearest strength. He rides beats with an easy, unhurried cadence that sounds like he is thinking out loud rather than reciting. On "Fragrance" he floats over the Jordan Rakei sample without fighting it; on "Designer" he shifts his pocket twice in the second verse and makes both transitions feel natural.

The problem is that his hooks often settle for melody over lyrical content—"Sanufa" coasts on the refrain, "PDA" uses the Devonté Hynes interpolation as a crutch—and the guest verses expose the gap. Cole's verse on "Tribe" is sharper and more specific than anything Bas delivers on the album; Ferg brings more presence to "Boca Raton" than the track asks for. Ari Lennox saves "Icarus" from drifting into background music. Bas holds his own, but he does not command his own record the way a third album demands.

A Sequence That Peaks Early

The album front-loads its best work. The opening stretch peaks on "Tribe," where Cole's production swings hard and both verses justify the runtime. The energy stays high through the first four tracks, then settles into a long middle section that never sags but never peaks either.

The sequencing earns its thirty-nine-minute runtime. The two interludes frame the album's movements without padding it, and the pacing keeps the energy even without flattening the dynamics. The bonus track adds four minutes and feels like one—an interesting experiment that does not belong in the main sequence.

The album does not overstay its welcome, but it also does not leave much room for peaks. By the closing run, the mood has been sustained but not developed. The whole record feels like one long groove rather than a journey with distinct chapters, and that works until you realize there is nowhere left to go.

A Dreamville Album in J. Cole's Image

Milky Way is Bas's most consistent album and his least ambitious. It ranks as a demonstration of his technical improvement—his flow is more controlled, his ear for production sharper—but it also reveals his limits as a writer and a conceptual thinker. The thesis about finding ground and loving yourself never moves past the announcement; the album coasts on vibe where it needed to dig. It belongs in the middle tier of Dreamville's catalog: well-executed, pleasant, and ultimately forgettable in a catalog that includes sharper and more distinctive records.

This is for fans of J. Cole's mellower production work, for listeners who value consistency and mood over peaks and risks, and for anyone looking for background music that never demands too much. Skip it if you want writing that matches the production, if you need hooks that stick after one listen, or if introspective claims need to be earned with specific details.

Start with "Tribe," then "Purge," then "Boca Raton"—if those three do not hold you, the rest will not either. If you finish this and want Bas at his sharpest, go back to Too High to Riot for higher peaks; if you want Dreamville at its best, Cole's 2014 Forest Hills Drive and 4 Your Eyez Only do more with similar production approaches. Milky Way found its lane and stayed in it. That is enough to make it solid. It is not enough to make it necessary.

Track by track

Track Listing

#Title
1

Icarus

Solid

Ari Lennox saves this opener from drifting into the background. Bas introduces the album's thesis about chasing validation in the wrong places, but the verse stays too general to land with weight. The Meez and Ron Gilmore production is airy and deliberate, built on slow Rhodes chords and a patient bassline. Lennox's hook does the emotional work Bas's verse only gestures toward—her voice adds warmth and specificity to the abstract claims. The sequencing choice is smart: it sets the mood without demanding too much too soon.

2

Front Desk

Standout

The album's smoothest groove: Jay Kurzweil and Cole build a beat that swings in the pocket without rushing, and Bas matches the energy with a conversational verse about late nights and small decisions. The writing is still more vibe than substance, but the delivery locks in. The hook is too slight to carry the track, but the production fills the gaps. Solid execution on a limited idea.

3

Tribe

Standout

The album's clearest peak and its best argument. Childish Major flips the Edu Lobo sample into a head-nod loop with enough room for both rappers to breathe, and Cole's verse is the sharpest writing on the record—specific, focused, built on internal rhymes that tighten as the verse progresses. Bas holds his own in the first verse with a clear narrative about loyalty and grounding, and the hook actually sticks. This is the only track where the thesis feels earned rather than announced. The sequencing is deliberate: "Tribe" arrives early enough to establish the album's high end, and nothing after it matches the energy.

4

Boca Raton

Standout

Sango flips Gil Scott-Heron into a Miami heat shimmer, all humidity and low-end bounce, and the production carries the track harder than either rapper. Bas delivers a solid first verse about the shift from New York to Florida, but Ferg's guest spot is the real event—he brings more presence and sharper punchlines than the beat asks for, and his energy lifts the whole song. The hook is slight, more rhythm than lyric, but the vibe is undeniable. This is the album's second-best track and its most replayable moment.

5

Barack Obama Special

Solid

Ron Gilmore flips the Oscar Peterson sample into a late-night jazz loop, and Bas coasts on the mood without adding much lyrically. The writing gestures at political and personal responsibility but never gets specific enough to land. The hook is a one-line refrain that functions as texture more than statement. It works as an interlude-length mood piece but runs a minute too long for what it delivers.

6

Purge

Standout

The album's writing peak. Bas names the problem directly—poisoning your own well, chasing validation from the wrong sources—and works through it in real time rather than announcing it from a distance. The production is sparse, just drums and a Michael Noyce sample that breathes in the background, and Bas uses the space well. The second verse is the album's most focused moment: he moves from self-examination to resolution without padding the idea. The hook is repetitive but earns it by anchoring the concept. This is what the whole album needed more of.

7

Fragrance

Solid

Brown and Cole flip the Jordan Rakei sample into a slow drift, and Bas floats over it with a verse about attraction and fleeting connection. The writing is more suggestive than specific, but the delivery is controlled—he shifts his cadence twice without forcing it. Correy C's additional vocals add texture in the outro. The track works as a mood piece but does not develop the idea enough to justify the runtime. Solid filler.

8

Infiniti

Solid

A twenty-second interlude pulling dialogue from White Men Can't Jump. It frames the shift into the album's second movement without disrupting the flow. Functional.

9

Infiniti+2

Weak

Jay Kurzweil flips the Gayngs sample into a skeletal loop, and Bas delivers two minutes of abstract self-examination. The writing is too vague to land—lines about infinity and doubling back gesture at depth without earning it. Correy C's vocals in the background add atmosphere but not clarity. This feels like a sketch that needed another verse to complete the thought.

10

Sanufa

Solid

Cole and Gilmore build a warm, mid-tempo groove, and Bas delivers a competent verse about intimacy and grounding. The writing is pleasant but unremarkable, and the hook leans too hard on the refrain without giving it lyrical weight. Rox Barker's additional vocals add texture in the outro. This is filler: not bad, not memorable, just there.

11

Great Ones

Solid

A thirty-five-second interlude pulling Chazz Palminteri's voice from A Bronx Tale. It frames the album's final stretch and lands without overstaying. Functional.

12

PDA

Solid

The production is the event: Ogee and company layer Devonté Hynes and Rodney Franklin samples into a slow-burn groove that rewards headphone listens. Bas delivers a verse about public affection and private connection, but the writing stays surface-level. The hook interpolates the sample rather than building on it. This works as a vibe track and holds up on repeat for the instrumental layers, but the rapping does not match the ambition of the beat.

13

Designer

Solid

The album's smoothest closer in the main sequence. Brown, Cole and company flip the Tom Misch sample into a low-key groove, and Bas delivers a verse about materialism and self-worth that gestures at depth without committing. The second verse shifts the pocket twice and both transitions feel natural, but the writing never sharpens into a point. Rox Barker's vocals add warmth in the outro. Solid execution on a limited idea; it ends the album on a pleasant note without delivering a climax.

14

Spaceships + Rockets

Solid

A bonus track that pulls from the Black Panther soundtrack's Gqom energy and adds LION BABE, Moe Moks and mOma+Guy to the mix. The production is the album's most adventurous moment, layering South African house rhythms with the album's jazz-inflected approach, but it does not belong in the main sequence—it disrupts the mood without adding to the thesis. Bas's verse is competent but the guest features do more work. Interesting experiment, unnecessary addition.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Bas Milky Way worth listening to?
Milky Way is worth one listen if you value consistent mood and J. Cole-style production over sharp writing. The album delivers thirty-nine minutes of smooth, jazz-inflected beats and controlled flow, with standout tracks like "Tribe," "Purge," and "Boca Raton." But the introspective claims stay surface-level, the hooks often coast on melody, and the writing rarely matches the ambition of the production. It is solid background music that does not demand much and does not offer much beyond the first impression.
What are the best songs on Bas Milky Way?
"Tribe" with J. Cole is the album's clear peak—sharp writing, a memorable hook, and production that swings hard. "Purge" is the writing high point, with Bas actually working through self-examination rather than just announcing it. "Boca Raton" with ASAP Ferg delivers the album's clearest energy, with Sango's production and Ferg's verse elevating the track. Start with those three; if they do not hold you, the rest of the album will not either.
How does Milky Way compare to Bas's other albums?
Milky Way is Bas's most consistent album and his most polished, with better production cohesion and more controlled delivery than Too High to Riot. But it is also his least ambitious—the introspective concept stays vague, the writing lacks the peaks of his earlier work, and the whole album prioritizes mood over risk. It is a step forward technically and a step sideways creatively.
Who produced Bas Milky Way?
J. Cole handled production or co-production on seven tracks and shaped the album's overall sound. Ron Gilmore co-produced ten of fourteen tracks and anchored the consistency. Other key contributors include Sango on "Boca Raton," Childish Major on "Tribe," Jay Kurzweil on "Front Desk" and "Infiniti+2," and Cedric Brown on multiple tracks. The production is sample-heavy, jazz-inflected, and built around negative space and low-end warmth.