The scorecard
7.5/10 · Great
- Writing25%
- 7.5
- Production25%
- 8.5
- Delivery15%
- 7.5
- Cohesion15%
- 6.5
- Originality10%
- 7.0
- Replay value10%
- 7.0
The depression chronicle delivers specific feeling in images like sobriety-as-hunger and withdrawal irritability, even where simple rhyme schemes and associative logic keep the narrative structure loose.
Cam O'bi, D. Sanders and Steve Lacy construct hazy soul-trap hybrids with live bass and chopped samples that let Rashad's rasp hover instead of punch.
The half-sung, half-mumbled cadence communicates numbness with real emotional weight, though the same druggy lilt across seventeen tracks means few gear shifts when the subject could use them.
The first half sequences a clear thesis with earned momentum, but seventeen tracks with cuts like "Dressed Like Rappers" arriving after the album said what it came to say add runtime the structure doesn't support.
Rashad refines Cilvia Demo's template without redefining it: the jazzy trap-soul palette and layered vocal approach were fresh in 2016 but the moves are familiar.
"Free Lunch" and "Wat's Wrong" hold up but the long runtime and tonal sameness mean most return listens skip the back half.
Isaiah Rashad The Sun's Tirade — The Weight That Wouldn't Lift
The Sun's Tirade makes the case for Isaiah Rashad as a mood architect and then proves he needed a better editor. The album documents two years of Xanax and alcohol dependence, near dismissal from Top Dawg Entertainment three times over, and the effort to make songs while numb. That premise delivers on the first half: Cam O'bi's jazz-sample haze on "Free Lunch" and the syrupy bassline on "Wat's Wrong" create actual sonic equivalents of dissociation, and Rashad's half-sung, half-mumbled flow sounds like someone trying to stay upright. But the thesis that depression is cyclical and formless does not justify seventeen tracks that circle the same feeling without escalation or release. By the time "Dressed Like Rappers" arrives with its complaints about fake flexing, the album has already said what it came to say, and the last third feels like a songwriter unable to choose what to cut. The result ranks below Cilvia Demo not because the highs are lower but because Rashad mistakes repetition for depth.
The FACT SHEET confirms that Rashad recorded this album while battling depression, anxiety and addiction, nearly losing his TDE deal in the process. That context matters because the sound is built to communicate fracture: vocals layered and warped, beats that never quite resolve, sequencing that refuses to build toward catharsis. The question is whether seventy minutes of that refusal becomes its own artistic statement or just an overstuffed tracklist. The Sun's Tirade lands somewhere in between, with enough moments of real songcraft to justify the acclaim and enough redundancy to explain why it disappeared from most playlists within a year.
Floating Versus Drowning
The production team constructs a Southern rap record filtered through neo-soul and trip-hop: live basslines, chopped jazz samples, trap hi-hats muffled under reverb. Cam O'bi's "Free Lunch" loops a warm guitar riff and lets Rashad coast over it, his cadence so relaxed it barely sounds like rapping. D. Sanders, who appears on five tracks, favors the same approach: slow tempos, thick low end, space for Rashad's voice to layer and echo. Steve Lacy's work on "Silkk da Shocka" brings live bass and a one-chord vamp that sounds like a jam session someone forgot to end. Mike Will Made It shows up for "A Lot" with a glitchier, more aggressive beat, but even there the mix buries the drums and foregrounds Rashad's harmonized vocals. The palette is consistent and the execution is strong, which means the production succeeds at the task Rashad set: making depression sound textured instead of flat.
The writing operates in the same mode throughout: Rashad catalogs bad decisions, failed relationships and self-medication without offering analysis or resolution. He describes popping pills, missing calls, disappointing women and feeling stuck, and the verses follow an associative logic where one image prompts the next without building an argument. The rhyme schemes are simple, often just assonance at the line breaks, and the wordplay is minimal. What distinguishes the better songs is specificity of feeling rather than craft: "Free Lunch" compares sobriety to hunger and nails the irritability of early withdrawal, while "Wat's Wrong" with Zacari and Kendrick Lamar describes a relationship unraveling in real time with small, accurate details. Kendrick Lamar's verse on that track highlights the gap: his internal rhymes and narrative control make Rashad's approach look looser and less considered than it needs to be.
The features do the work Rashad's writing does not. SiR on "Rope // rosegold" provides melodic counterpoint, Syd on "Silkk da Shocka" trades verses with real vocal personality, and Jay Rock on "Tity and Dolla" brings the only hard-edged verse on the album. SZA's hook on "Stuck in the Mud" is the album's best moment of actual songwriting: a melodic phrase with shape and payoff. Where Rashad floats, the guests anchor. The issue is that over seventeen tracks, floating starts to feel like stalling, and the lack of narrative or sonic development becomes a choice the album never earns.
Seventy Minutes of the Same Afternoon
The album peaks early and often in the first half, then spends the second half repeating gestures without raising stakes. The opening stretch works as both standalone material and thesis statement: production stays detailed, hooks land, and verses describe the problem clearly enough to hold attention. The following run maintains momentum with tighter runtimes and actual dynamics, one track switching between sung and rapped verses, another giving the bassline room to build tension by walking instead of drifting. The longest track in the first stretch runs over seven minutes but justifies the length with a guest performance and a beat that shifts textures halfway through.
After that the sequencing loses direction. The middle section revisits the same substance-abuse themes without new details, introduces tangents about image the album has not set up, and offers character sketches that arrive too late to reframe anything. The back half needed either a narrative turn or a sonic shift, and it provides neither. The closing run ends with the kind of self-aware title that suggests Rashad knew he was stretching the concept thin. The problem is not that individual tracks fail but that the album refuses to edit itself, and the refusal reads as indecision rather than artistic choice. Cilvia Demo ran under forty minutes and used every one; The Sun's Tirade runs seventy and earns about half.
The Better Version Is Forty Minutes Long
The Sun's Tirade ranks below Cilvia Demo because it takes the earlier project's strengths—mood, texture, Rashad's understated delivery—and stretches them past the point where they create meaning. Cilvia Demo felt like a songwriter discovering what he could do with minimalism; this feels like a songwriter who discovered one trick and used it seventeen times. The production is strong throughout, the features elevate every track they touch, and the first half justifies the critical acclaim the album received in 2016. But the second half is filler in the most literal sense: songs that occupy space without advancing the album's emotional or sonic argument. Fans who loved Cilvia Demo will find moments here worth keeping, but they will also find themselves making a ten-track playlist and skipping the rest.
Start with "Free Lunch," "Wat's Wrong" and "Stuck in the Mud" to hear the album's best work: writing that describes a specific kind of numbness, production that makes that numbness audible, and guests who provide the melodic and narrative backbone Rashad does not. Skip this if you want rapping with craft and wordplay; Rashad's writing is all feeling and no technique, and over seventy minutes that limitation becomes the album's ceiling. For a clearer, sharper version of this approach, go back to Cilvia Demo. For what Rashad does when he tightens the focus and cuts the runtime, the next album The House Is Burning shows him learning the lesson this one refused to teach. The Sun's Tirade captures a real moment of struggle but mistakes documentation for structure, and the difference costs it a place among TDE's essential releases.
Track by track
Track Listing
where u at?
SolidA forty-four second intro with Rashad mumbling a question over muffled noise. Sets the disoriented tone but does not earn its own track slot.
4r Da Squaw
StandoutFrancisGotHeat's beat has a warped vocal sample and snapping percussion, and Rashad delivers one of his tightest verses, using internal rhymes and a faster flow than he will maintain later. The writing catalogs mistakes and regrets without self-pity, and the hook's repetition builds momentum instead of dragging. The track works as both a song and a mission statement: Rashad can write when he wants to.
Free Lunch
StandoutCam O'bi loops a clean guitar riff and Rashad describes sobriety as unwanted hunger, the verses capturing the irritability and low-grade desperation of early withdrawal. The metaphor is simple but the execution is specific: he is not preaching recovery or wallowing, just describing what it feels like to want what is killing you. The mix buries his voice slightly, making the delivery feel even more internal. The song became the album's calling card because it condenses the entire thesis into three minutes.
Rope // rosegold
StandoutTwo beats stitched together: J. LBS. and The Antydote build a slow, bass-heavy groove and SiR sings a spacey melody that contrasts with Rashad's lower register. The transition between the two sections is seamless and the runtime justifies the structure. SiR's presence gives the track a dynamic Rashad cannot create alone, and the production allows both vocalists to work in their pockets without competing. One of the album's most fully realized songs.
Wat’s Wrong
StandoutD. Sanders and Al B. Smoov construct a slinky, off-kilter beat with live bass and Zacari provides a drowsy, melodic hook about a relationship falling apart. Rashad describes the same situation from his perspective with small, accurate details—missed calls, half-apologies, the sense that both people know it is over but neither will say it. Kendrick's verse is the album's sharpest writing: internal rhymes, narrative control and a clear point of view. His appearance also highlights that Rashad is working in a looser, less technically demanding mode. Still, the song works because all three vocalists commit to the same feeling.
Park
SolidPark Ave. and D. Sanders lay down a walking bassline and Rashad floats over it with a sing-song flow, the lyrics cataloging substance use and detachment. The track is economical at under three minutes and the production has enough movement to hold attention. Solid but not essential.
Bday
SolidTiggi and Deacon Blues build a brighter, more uptempo beat and Kari Faux adds a verse with more energy than Rashad has shown so far. The subject is partying and flexing, a tonal shift the album has not earned. The track feels like an attempt at variety that works against the album's central argument. Decent as a one-off but misplaced in the sequence.
Silkk Da Shocka
StandoutSteve Lacy plays a hypnotic one-chord bassline and Syd trades verses with Rashad, her delivery more direct and grounded than his. The chemistry is strong and the minimalist production gives both rappers room to work. The song meanders lyrically but the vibe is so locked in it does not matter. A mood piece that earns its runtime.
Tity and Dolla
StandoutCrooklin and Pops build a harder, more traditional Southern rap beat and Jay Rock delivers the only aggressive verse on the album, providing a jolt of energy the surrounding tracks lack. Rashad and Hugh Augustine match the tone and the track works as a brief detour into something closer to a posse cut. The sequencing is smart: the album needed a palate cleanser here.
Stuck in the Mud
StandoutOver seven minutes, D. Sanders and Crooklin build a beat that shifts textures halfway through, and SZA provides the album's best melodic hook: a sung phrase with real shape and emotional payoff. Rashad uses the runtime to explore the same theme from multiple angles—feeling trapped, self-medicating, watching relationships dissolve—and the length feels justified because the production evolves and SZA's presence keeps the song from becoming monotonous. The album's longest track and one of its best.
A lot
SolidMike Will Made It brings a glitchy, more aggressive beat but the mix still buries the drums and foregrounds Rashad's layered vocals. The writing revisits substance abuse without new details or insights. The production is interesting but the song does not justify its inclusion this deep in the tracklist.
AA
WeakDzonybeats and D. Sanders construct another hazy beat and Rashad delivers another set of verses about pills and detachment. The craft is competent but the album has already made this point multiple times. Filler.
Dressed Like Rappers
WeakDK the Punisher builds a beat with more bounce and Rashad complains about image-conscious rappers and fake flexing, a tangent the album has not set up. The subject feels imported from a different project and the writing lacks the specificity that makes the better tracks land. Skippable.
Don’t Matter
SolidThe Antydote and Carter Lang deliver a mellow, bass-heavy groove and Lance Skiiiwalker contributes a brief vocal that does not add much. Rashad revisits relationship dysfunction in the most general terms. The song drifts without incident.
Brenda
SolidCalor's production is warm and jazzy and Rashad offers a character sketch about a woman navigating hardship. The writing is more narrative than usual but arrives too late in the sequence to reframe the album. Decent but misplaced.
by george (outro)
SolidAn instrumental outro with a looped sample and no vocals. Pleasant but unnecessary as its own track.
Find a Topic (homies begged)
WeakFree P and J. LBS. build a minimal beat and Rashad delivers a self-aware verse acknowledging that he is out of things to say. The title is the most honest moment on the back half. Should have been a signal to end the album ten tracks earlier.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The Sun's Tirade better than Cilvia Demo?
What is Isaiah Rashad's The Sun's Tirade about?
What are the best songs on The Sun's Tirade?
Genres




